THIRD SUNDAY OF EASTER 2009 YEAR B
Written by Fr. Kevin O'Shea, C.Ss.R.
THIRD SUNDAY OF EASTER 2009 YEAR BHOW REAL IS THE RESURRECTION?April 19, 2009Lk 24, 35-38
The gospel today, from Luke, raises questions a lot of people have and never put words on. The main one is: did Jesus really rise from the dead? What do you mean by ‘really’? Yes, it is hard to put words on that. The answer is unequivocally yes, he did rise really. The consequences are, indeed, hard to spell out. Dead bodies stay dead, don’t they? I think the whole drift of the scriptural evidence is that some unparalleled phenomenon happened to Jesus. It is not like something we are familiar with, and we can’t use our ordinary language to talk about it. But it is something very real. It is not just an impression, or a conviction, or a gift of faith given to disciples to think like that about Jesus. It really happened to him.
On the surface, there are seeming contradictions in the accounts of it. No New Testament writer ever thought that the risen Jesus would die again. Having died once, he dies no more. But Luke describes, in today’s gospel, the risen body of Jesus as something you can look at and see, something you can touch and hold, since it is flesh and bones, with hands and feet. It is a body that can eat. But it does not occur to Luke that such a body can die, and normally will die, and neither Luke nor anyone else imagined God intervening all the time to stop that happening. A risen body, and especially that of Jesus, would naturally and by its own make-up, be unable to die again. So what does Luke mean by describing it as he does? Again, how real is it really?
Even the laws of physics demand that bodies such as those we have – or any bodies made of the matter in our universe – will disintegrate. You can’t live a risen life, or eternal life, with a body like that. You can’t turn God into an eternal blocking system stopping nature be what it really is. If you did take on the same sort of body after your death, it could only be another round of the same mortal kind of life.
The scene is set amid a number of ‘stories of recognition’ (that’s almost the title Luke uses). Here Luke insists that it is really Jesus, really he, that is recognized. Not a ghost, but the alive, real man. That’s the point – leave out the tricky questions! [I find it interesting that according to the New Testament record, it was the holy women who first recognized Jesus risen. And yet, all the consequent recognition scenes in which men meet Jesus, are written up as if they were the first! I suppose each one was unique in its own way…] Luke, following Mark, stresses the fact that those who recognized Jesus were more than just afraid, they were scared out of their wits. Literally, I think. They were saying things that did not make sense to someone in their right mind. Mark has them saying nothing (a good option). Luke makes them say things, but without much rational coherence. Herbert McCabe says they recognized Jesus as the man they had sort of known and thought they knew, but didn’t really know until now.
Let me make the problem even harder. A resurrection is not something that can be verified empirically. There’s no hard object at five paces. At the same time, I think it is more than an act of faith in a paradox that doesn’t add up. It is a real thing for the person risen, not just a subjective persuasion in the person who believes it. So – how can it be real?
I’d like to go back to a thought that came from the church Fathers in the east in the early centuries (Origen, Gregory of Nyssa…). They talked about ‘spiritual senses’. They didn’t mean pious feelings. They meant that we all have a kind of loving awareness of things that the hard-wired left brain doesn’t know anything about. In this loving awareness, we can ‘picture’ things that strictly are not subjects for pictures. We do so to make as real as we can for ourselves what we, much deeper down, know is real in ways that are beyond all our pictures. It is, you could say, subliminal. It is like a stream of life and wonder. It is like touching an original un-spoilt world that we don’t usually live in.
Let’s use a contemporary Irish poem to illustrate it.
He stumped us, this Jesus of yours, with hisWalking on water, fandango, entrechat, glissade;Birthing, imagine! In a dark cave, out of all knowing, thenHe walked the hard-baked earth of Palestine, but notAs you walk, or as I, for behind him the healing flowers grew,The rosebay willowherb, chamomile, the John’s Wort;We noted, too, that he could walk through walls,Appearing suddenly in the midst of folk as ifHe were always there, waiting that they might notice him.Oh yes, this too, he walked on airLeaving them gasping upwards as he roseHigher and higher, like a skylark, walkingInto the invisible. That was later. But humankindWill not be cheated of its prey for we claimed him,Nailing him fast to a tree, that he could not moveOn water, earth, or air, and we buried him in the underearth.Where, it is said, he took to walking once again,Singing his larksong to the startled, to the stumped, dead.
John F. Deane, Words of the Unknown Soldier
What this way of perceiving does is get very close to the ‘flame’ inside us that is the very life we live by. As life moves forward for us, that ‘flame’ is ‘rising’ to new levels. When we have the experience of recognizing a risen person, that recognition intensifies the rising of that flame inside us, and we ‘know’. The question isn’t actually, how real is the resurrection? but how do we perceive the resurrection of someone to be real? That’s the answer to that part of the question.
That’s why – to deal with Jesus’ resurrection – the early disciples used a kind of poetry they never used before (and neither did anyone else). They touched Jesus. They felt the pulse in his veins, in his wounds. They saw him break bread and eat it. They never forgot the taste of that bread. They knew – deep down – this was He who had broken bread with the poor of Galilee. Whenever they did that in the future, themselves, they were doing this new poetry and telling themselves he was there, with them, doing it again.
It’s real all right. I find it sad that some believers today get insistent on a literal, physical realism of the risen body of Jesus. As if that were the only reality! I find it sad because the resurrection was more than that, and they are missing the point and the real mystery. I find it just as sad when others accuse those who use this real-poetry of just making up fables and such like. I find it sad because they don’t hear the real music within, or the real mystery – the really real reality.
Surrexit Dominus VERE… He has risen REALLY and made us more REAL than we ever were.

No comments:
Post a Comment