Monday, May 4, 2009

FOURTH SUNDAY OF EASTER, 3, 2009, Jn 10,11-18, B


FOURTH SUNDAY OF EASTER


Written by Fr. Kevin O'Shea, C.Ss.R.

FOURTH SUNDAY OF EASTERA SHEPHERD FOR MANY SHEEPMay 3, 2009Jn 10, 11-18
Today is often called ‘Good Shepherd’ Sunday. The gospel, from John, presents Jesus as the good shepherd, not just of one flock, but of many. ‘Other sheep I have that are not of this fold…’For this reason, we think ecumenically on this Sunday, and pray for the eventual coming together of all the various groups that believe in the one Shepherd of all. That Shepherd already owns them all. I would like to suggest a sense of history – we need to know, as clearly as we can, where we have come from, if we would see where to go from here.
In fact, the variety of such groups is not just the result of unfortunate divisions of a single central Christianity in the beginning. There were already many diverse groups of believers in the earliest days. As new situations arose, they responded in different and still more diverse ways. History is the record of this increasing multiplicity. Often Christians have been brought up with the idea that the ‘one true church’ (the one they belong to now) was there as such from the start, with no competing varieties: this is not really so. There were lots of versions of Christianity, and the Good Shepherd was good enough to include them all in his love and care.
There was an uprising of the Jews of Judea against the Romans, that led to the war of 66-70 and the destruction of Jerusalem and its temple. All the Jerusalem based groups of Jesus believers faded out from that time. There are traces of them for a while in Galilee and in Syria. Only the Pauline communities of the Diaspora, survived. All of us now are descendants of these Pauline communities.
Soon they faced a new issue: they expected the imminent return of Jesus. It didn’t happen. Was it a false hope? Would they have to see themselves as ‘in for the long term’ of history, without Jesus’ return? They would. Would they have to be inculturated into the Roman empire? They would. As a result, would they lose something of their distinctive identity? They would. How did they reaffirm it? By reviving the sense of their origin from Israel (they read again the Jewish scriptures with the commandments and the stories of the heroes), and their sense of origin from Paul (they collected and read his letters). Some people were more pro Israel, others more pro Paul. There was much diversity among them.
In the middle of the second century these ‘Christians’ were socially inconspicuous and practically invisible. It is only in the early third century that they own land, build catacombs, and eventually churches, and so create ‘Christian spaces’ or sanctuaries of their own. It is much later that they develop a tradition of doctrines (Jesus was born of a virgin, died to atone for our sins, rose from the dead in his own body, and helps us here so we can go to heaven when we die). What we take as the one and only true and orthodox Christianity comes slowly, and quite late, amid many other interpretations of Christianity.
Although local persecutions had always been around, there is no official, empire-wide attempt to persecute and eliminate Christians before the middle of 3rd century – it increased in the very early 4th century. It lasted until 313, when Constantine proclaimed official tolerance of Christians in the whole Western and Eastern Empire, and made religion a matter of free choice. Then ‘Christians’ were a public, accepted social reality. But it was only one ‘version’ of belief in Christ that was accepted by Constantine. Other versions went ‘underground’. Most disappeared.
From a background that had as many points as a compass, there emerged one brand of ‘orthodoxy’. Earlier, some were more positive about Israel, others less; some more positive about Paul, others less; some more into institutional structures for Christian experience, others less; some more into doctrines and formulas of faith, others less. Eventually, after Constantine, what ‘gelled’ was one proto-orthodox ‘religion’. Only the proto-orthodox could have developed into the explicit teaching that Jesus was both divine and human, and that there were three persons in God. By the end of the second century, only the proto-orthodox remain: the rest are ‘history’.
Sometimes Roman Catholics now have little or no sense of this background. They have a vague idea that the Reformation split away from the Catholic Church, and that ‘we’ inherited the ‘right’ side of that argument, and that the ‘others’ got the wrong side. They tend to claim the Good Shepherd for themselves exclusively. That isn’t right.
Yes, there are differences, some of them irreconcilable, among all the many Christian groups. We desire more unity. We pray for it. We wait for it. We know that we don’t know how to get it all together yet. We see all our pasts as pretty ‘messed up’, with troubles on both and many sides of most questions.
All this affects the idea people have of Jesus. In fact, it affects the idea people have of God. Much of the argument in the very early communities was about the kind of God (or the kind of Jesus) who could be a good shepherd for all. They had trouble with a ‘heavy’ kind of God. They wanted, without clear definition, a ‘gentle’ or ‘open’ kind of God. Most of the ‘diversity’ in the early churches comes from this discussion about God.
The point today is that the Good Shepherd, Jesus, was the shepherd of all these sheep in so many folds. They all believed in him. He believed in them all. We love and take pride in our tradition, but we must realize it comes out of a background of many (diverse) traditions.
Something is happening among us now. We are changing our idea of ‘ecumenism’. We used to think it meant that one day all these ‘wrong’ versions would have a conversion and come back to us, the right ones. We held the high moral ground, and it was the one and only real ground. Now we know we are not that. We have learnt some humility. We are smaller than we used to be. We are about the same size and the same level of importance or unimportance as most of the ‘opposition’. We recognize that not only in our past, but in our contemporary life, we are ‘one among many’. We are beginning to sense that the top priority isn’t being in the one ‘right’ fold but having the one Good Shepherd. As a result, we are re-conceiving our Christian vocation today. We see ourselves as a small (minority) group, with its own treasured internal life, and with a real influence on the ‘big world’ of other religious persuasions and of secular attitudes, all around us. We are not the answer to prayer for everyone, we are just praying that everyone finds the answer to the prayer that is real for them.
So, maybe the future isn’t what some would like. Maybe we won’t have another golden age of the dominance of the Catholic ways of doing things (a sort of repeat of life after Trent). Maybe we will learn a different way of being good sheep, even if we aren’t in the same sort of sheepfold we have been used to. The good news is that the Shepherd isn’t different, just the same, only more so.
If you let a sheep stand on its own four feet, and try to be independent, it’s hard to handle. If you hold it up, it usually calms down, and you can get the surplus wool off it. The Good Shepherd knows how to hold up sheep that want to be too independent…even very orthodox ones!

No comments: