Monday, May 4, 2009

SECOND SUNDAY OF EASTER, B, Jn 20,19-31


SECOND SUNDAY OF EASTER


Written by Fr. Kevin O'Shea, C.Ss.R.

SECOND SUNDAY OF EASTER ROOM FOR EVERYONEApril 19 2009Jn 20, 19-31

Today we read the story of Thomas, the apostle, coming to faith in the resurrection of Jesus. He had not been present at earlier appearances of the risen Jesus to his own. They believed because of these appearances: Thomas didn’t yet believe, because he hadn’t had one. He presents like a really hard-nosed sceptic: ‘unless I can prove it, I won’t believe’. Jesus appears to him. Jesus tells him to doubt no longer, but believe. He does. He has a very personal experience of Jesus. He prays: “My Lord and My God!” [It is the expression you find in many Irish prayers, still.] In many ways, today is like a wrap-up of Easter, and many would identify with Thomas. [Today is also celebrated as ‘Mercy’ Sunday, and that too is like a wrap-up of the key theme of Mercy in the whole Easter Mystery.]

Thomas, however, stands in the fourth gospel for a whole group of people, and I would like to talk about them. They are people who have come to some very private experience of Jesus, who is alive to them in a special way. Through their experience of his presence in their lives, they live with some kind of ‘secret’ (or intimate, or personal) knowledge of Jesus. They usually don’t tell anyone. If they do, they often get misunderstood, rejected, even persecuted (by others who don’t live basically off such an interior experience of Jesus). Often, then, they cherish their ‘private life with Jesus’ much more, and their ‘knowledge’ of Jesus tends to become more satisfying than what is publicly said about Jesus, and so more ‘spiritual’ and more ‘sacred’. It has a real priority in guiding their lives. They see it as the real ‘secret of faith’, and wish it were more included in the public teaching of the large church. There were whole groups of people like this in the very early days of believers in Jesus. ‘Thomas’ is taken as their symbolic ‘patron saint’. What they were looking for, was acceptance and inclusion in the mainstream of the very early church. That inclusion wasn’t all that easy.

The general attitude of most ‘ordinary believers’ (as we see if we read Mark, Matthew or Luke) was realistic and ‘out there’. It was anchored in real history. It told stories of the way ordinary people responded in the open, publicly, to a well-known and public Jesus. It told the story of the way this Jesus stood up for the real poor, was challenged by public authority for doing so, never backed down, and so was eliminated by crucifixion. It told the story of his resurrection, as a continuation of what he was trying to do in his historical life, as a divinely-set-up way of still affecting humans in real need. It all looked to a different future for everyone. The synoptic tradition (Mark, Matthew, Luke) was not really interested in including in the gospel anything much of the ‘Thomas tradition’ of interior, private, ‘secret’ understanding of Jesus.

Still in the first century, but a little later than most of the above, we have the gospel of John. This gospel did try to include something of the ‘Thomas tradition’. That is why, at the climax of that gospel, we have (in today’s reading) the story of the coming to faith of Thomas himself.
To include this spiritual tradition, the fourth gospel had to walk a tightrope. Between what is called ‘Gnosticism’ and what is called ‘Orthodoxy’.

There was never such a thing as a ‘Gnostic religion’ separate from Judaism and/or Christianity. Gnosticism appeared first inside Judaism. It was one way of reading the Hebrew Scriptures. It read them in the light of some going Greek philosophies (especially Middle Platonist cosmology and anthropology). The Greek word gnosis means knowledge. If you thought like that, you could be called a ‘Gnostic’, while remaining a Jew. This was a religious current that had been brewing for some time. It appeared among some of the early believers in Jesus, (Jewish and Greek). It put a frame around some of their (genuine) spiritual experiences.

For them, ‘gnosis’ (knowledge) began to mean self-knowledge. They thought that the human soul was of heavenly origin, but was the result of a false step by a divine power. Each of us is a divine soul imprisoned in a material body. As a result we are unaware of who we really are. Our Savior (whoever that is) calls us to wake up from this sleep. He does so by asking us to look at some questions: who were we? Into what have we been thrown? Whither are we hastening? From what are we saved? What is birth? What is rebirth? Gnostics develop a history of the human self (as a spark of light imprisoned in darkness). Speaking generally, the Gnostics separated the creator god of the Hebrew Bible, understood in their own way, from the story of the God who allegedly came in Jesus to help the little people of the world. They did not like the too-simplistic story of what Jesus did, and why he died and rose. They did not believe in such a ‘God’. They wanted a God who was spiritually leading people to more and more self-knowledge, and more and more distance from the present world.
I think there were many little groups around in early ‘Christianity’ that had inner-spiritual experiences of the risen Jesus, and were considered to be ‘too Gnostic’ by other believers. Again, ‘Thomas’ is a good cover-all heading for them. In the fourth gospel, John gives a special place to the story of a Thomas (one of the twelve) who came to faith by inner experience, and who looked a bit like a Gnostic but wasn’t one – he was as good a believer as those who came to Jesus in a more public and earthy way. Maybe even a better one.

We tend nowadays to assume that the ‘public and earthy’ way was always the ‘right’ way, and that, at best, all we can do is tolerate some of the ‘spirituals’ if we are in a good mood. Historically, it wasn’t like that. In the early days, there were many diverse forms of groups believing in Jesus. It took a long time, after the shake-down of the 2nd and 3rd centuries, before powerful influences in Alexandria, Antioch and Rome pressured Christianity into one dominant form, which has by and large remained the one and only such form down the centuries. Because of that, we tend, looking back, to call the other ways ‘heretical’. [That is a label applied post-factum by winners to losers.] It is not helpful to speak of orthodox vs heretical groups in the very early times. Or to speak of mainstream vs alternative groups then.

When John wrote his gospel, that ‘mainstream orthodoxy’ hadn’t emerged. John seems to come from a group that believed in inner-spiritual experiences more than others did. He was in a position to recognize, and include, some of the groups like his own, in what he saw as a larger and more fluid current of faith. He strongly opposed the real Gnostic thinking, because he thought they got the Hebrew Scriptures wrong, but he left the door open for ‘experience-faith’ that was not Gnostic, and that was not as ‘earthy-public-out-there’ as the synoptic tradition. John uses the story of Thomas, an insider, who had his own very private experience, to validate all the groups Thomas symbolizes. There is actually a document called the ‘Gospel of Thomas’. It is mid-first century, perhaps, or a little later, around the time of John, probably from Eastern Syria. It is neither heretical, nor Gnostic, nor an aberration, but it is not ‘mainstream orthodox’ in the sense of the synoptic gospels or the later emerged Christianity. It isn’t included in our canon. Our fourth gospel is often a good sparring partner for it! It
is 114 sayings of the risen Jesus…but no story of the earthy Jesus! It is readily available now in English translation.

People today have many different approaches to faith, to faith in the risen Jesus. Some are more out-there, some are more ‘in the heart’. Perhaps a re-reading of John’s story of Thomas’ coming to faith can show us that there is room for all of us in the resurrection.

No comments: